An Idea/Suggestion

[Dakkadakkadakka]

(05-15-2012 05:36 PM)Prelauncher Wrote:  Your idea is interesting but I don´t think it would work in Amnesia as it is now, it would not ruin the game for LP:ers etc. if it worked as an option, but still; it would not work. There is no need for the player to be able to talk during the game, there are no conversations (you mostly listen to old conversations) and there´s nothing that would be enhanced by using your voice. Now, Amnesia scared me the first time I played it, and other games have also scared me, but I never scream or do things like that. So why would one need a microphone?

Hm, I think you misunderstood the purpose of the voice option here. If you spoke while just running around, and having no monsters around, it wouldn't have any affect on the game. The only purpose is to make you have to be quiet while hiding from a monster. In some respect, this is already the case (you can't throw something while hiding without making a noise that will make a monster come after you, for example).

As for your second point.. all I can say is that not everyone reacts to the game like you. I certainly have an initial 'yelp' whenever something scares me. Some people can't stop whimpering or yelling. Everyone's different.

[Prelauncher]

(05-19-2012 07:31 PM)Dakkadakkadakka Wrote:  Hm, I think you misunderstood the purpose of the voice option here. If you spoke while just running around, and having no monsters around, it wouldn't have any affect on the game. The only purpose is to make you have to be quiet while hiding from a monster. In some respect, this is already the case (you can't throw something while hiding without making a noise that will make a monster come after you, for example).

As for your second point.. all I can say is that not everyone reacts to the game like you. I certainly have an initial 'yelp' whenever something scares me. Some people can't stop whimpering or yelling. Everyone's different.

I can assure you that I am fully aware about other peoples play styles differs from mine, but I do not see the point in going through all the trouble to implement this feature into the game when its only purpose is to punish people for the way they play (I know it sounds harsh but that's what it is).

[cantremember]

I guess it has some merit, but personally I don't think it would work well. I don't think many people actually scream out loud when playing video games, they only do that for youtube, or when they have someone over, in which case it wouldn't be fun that you can't talk to your friend anymore.