Tech Demo vs Overture vs Black Plague

[ZaRboN]

sybesis Wrote:Aw you just ruin my day...spoil tag aren't here for nothing

hey dude, don't worry
he lied xddd he didn't say the truth!
rly, the episode doesn't ends as finding your father trust me


best game of all three....it's very hard to decide.
like Scraper said, every game and his way!
ZaRboN's choice: Tech Demo! xd
Overture and Black Plague seemed...TOO OFFICIAL, TOO THINKING..
And I can explain myself with the easiest way like this:
what is better: Splinter Cell 2 or Another World?

[Kedjane]

The Tech Demo. It got all this started, was so promising and back then all this "open stuff with your mouse" and being defenseless was totally new. Now I think they've ruined the freshness of it.

[sybesis]

ZaRboN Wrote:hey dude, don't worry
he lied xddd he didn't say the truth!
rly, the episode doesn't ends as finding your father trust me

Now i'm confused so thats a good thing...there is a mystery...

[ZaRboN]

sybesis Wrote:

ZaRboN Wrote:hey dude, don't worry
he lied xddd he didn't say the truth!
rly, the episode doesn't ends as finding your father trust me

Now i'm confused so thats a good thing...there is a mystery...

That's excatly what u need to think
WE ALL FOOL YA! xd

[Petike]

My personal ranking for all the three games in the series - divided into several cathegories considering the design and gameplay :

Horror feel and atmosphere
1. Black Plague / Overture - it's a tie ;-)
2. Tech Demo

Action
1. Overture
2. Black Plague
3. Tech Demo

Puzzles
1. Overture / Black Plague - it's a tie
2. Tech Demo

Level layout design
1. Tech Demo
2. Overture / Black Plague - another tie, but BP seemed less predictable...

Philip's voice acting
1. Overture
2. Tech Demo
3. Black Plague

:-) That's my little opinion.


P.S. Last (and final) update : 10. June 2008

[ZaRboN]

Shup, you forgot music!!!
Althought there are so many great music files in Overture and Black Plague (I'm seriously saying this..omg xd), mystery.mp3 beats all (from Tech Demo)!!!!!




jk...i can't decide which has the best music. just too hard!

[Scraper]

Petike Wrote:Philip's voice acting
1. Overture
2. Tech Demo
3. Black Plague

How can you put Black Plague into last place and Overture into first?

I didn't like Overture's Philip that much...

My opinion is this:

1. Black Plague
2. Tech Demo
3. Overture

[jo291]

voice acting for phillip for me would be

1.black plague/overture it is a tie i cant decide! both games voice actors for phillip always had that certan tone of voice that made me feel depressed and wondering what fate had instore for him next.

2.tech demo it was just some decent voice acting witch sounded kinda like he was a computer generated voice witch was kinda lame.i didint really dwell on that seeing as they had no money at the time.

[Petike]

jo291 Wrote:2.tech demo it was just some decent voice acting witch sounded kinda like he was a computer generated voice witch was kinda lame.i didint really dwell on that seeing as they had no money at the time.

Ok, jo... :-)
I admit, that you have a point there with no. 1.
I just liked Tom Jubbert's voice because he wasn't overacting the role and gave Philip a real distinctive British feel (well, the hero is supposed to be an English bloke, right ?). The Philip of Black Plague had a cool voice as well, but I just hated the fact, how it broke the continuity of the character : http://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/sho...p?tid=2107
But yeah, it's a tie... :-)

And about no. 2. :
The Philip of the TechDemo was actually Mike Hillard, who later voiced Red in Overture... ;-)

[ZaRboN]

RED'S VOICE ROX!!!
And I think 99% agree with that.

Oh, and Clarence's voice fits his personallity so much it amaze me every time!