Whats scarier penumbra black plague or Overture

[Skaruts]

I have a hard time deciding which is scarier because, unlike most ppl (from what I've read around the forums) I focused on playing Overture without exploiting the fact that dogs died and such. Sure I killed a couple of dogs, mainly those that would make me lose too much time, due to having to bypass them plenty of times, but I killed no more than I needed to, and I still stealthed and fled my way through many of them many times.

Overture satisfied me even more than Black Plague did (I played the series in reverse, except for the 3rd one). The story felt stronger than BP's, Red was an amazing character, and the ending is just pure epicness.

I think both are scary, I can't decide. But I think Overture touched me a bit more, especialy because of Red.